← Blog

What Counts as Covered Goods: Coins, Numismatics, Scrap, and Industrial Metal

The dealer rule counts only purchases and sales of covered goods. Get the definition wrong and you get the $50,000 thresholds wrong, in either direction. Most of the hard cases in a coin or bullion business come from five places: numismatic coins, low-purity scrap, trade-ins, metal bought for industrial use, and silver.

The definition

Under 31 CFR 1027.100(a), covered goods are:

  • Jewels, meaning organic gem-quality substances such as pearl, amber, and coral (1027.100(c)).
  • Precious metals, meaning gold, iridium, osmium, palladium, platinum, rhodium, ruthenium, or silver at a purity of 500 parts per thousand or more, and alloys of two or more of those metals that reach 500 parts per thousand in the aggregate (1027.100(d)).
  • Precious stones, a defined list that includes diamond, ruby, sapphire, emerald, and opal, among others (1027.100(e)).
  • Finished goods, "including, but not limited to, jewelry, numismatic items, and antiques," that derive 50 percent or more of their value from the jewels, precious metals, or precious stones they contain (1027.100(a)(4)).

A business is a dealer only if, in the prior calendar or tax year, it both purchased more than $50,000 in covered goods and received more than $50,000 in gross proceeds from selling them (1027.100(b)(1)). Our post Are You a Dealer Under the BSA? covers the thresholds and the retailer exception.

Bullion and modern coins

Gold and silver bars, rounds, and bullion coins are covered goods. They are precious metal well above the purity floor. A 22-karat gold coin is about 917 parts per thousand gold, and a 90 percent silver coin is 900 parts per thousand. Count every purchase and sale of them toward the thresholds.

Numismatic coins

A collector coin is a finished good. The rule names "numismatic items" expressly. It is a covered good only if 50 percent or more of its value comes from its metal. That turns on price, not on the label:

  • A common-date gold coin trading near melt value is a covered good.
  • A rare coin whose price is mostly collector premium, with metal worth less than half the price, is not.

There is a second rule for the arithmetic. When you apply the $50,000 thresholds to finished goods, "only the value of jewels, precious metals, or precious stones contained in, or attached to, such goods shall be taken into account" (1027.100(b)(5)). A $10,000 coin with $6,000 of gold in it is a covered good, and it adds $6,000, not $10,000, to your threshold count.

Because coin prices move, a coin can cross the 50 percent line in either direction. A dealer with a large numismatic business should decide how it values the metal share (for example, the spot price on the transaction date), write the method into its records, and apply it the same way every year.

Scrap and low-purity items

Purity comes first. In ruling FIN-2012-R002, FinCEN said a business must first decide whether a finished good contains "precious metal" as the rule defines it. Metal below 500 parts per thousand is not precious metal, so a finished good made from it is not a covered good, "even when the value of such metals constitutes more than 50 percent of the value of the finished good."

For gold, the line falls between 10-karat (about 417 parts per thousand) and 14-karat (about 583). So 10-karat scrap jewelry is not a covered good on its metal content alone. A 10-karat ring with a diamond worth more than half its value would still be one, through the stone. Sort scrap by karat at intake if it matters to your thresholds, and keep the intake records.

Trade-ins for store credit

A trade-in is not a purchase for threshold purposes when the dealer or retailer credits the value to the customer's account and pays no funds (1027.100(b)(3)). A customer who trades an old chain toward a new ring has not sold you covered goods under the rule. A customer who takes cash, a check, or a transfer for the same chain has.

Metal bought for industrial use

The rule carves out industrial use: "purchase" and "sale" do not include buying jewels, precious metals, or precious stones "that are incorporated into machinery or equipment to be used for industrial purposes," or buying and selling that machinery or equipment (1027.100(b)(4)). Platinum in a catalytic converter assembly, gold in an electronics component, and diamond on an industrial saw blade bought as equipment fall outside the count.

The carve-out is narrow. It covers metal incorporated into machinery or equipment. It does not cover a refiner or recycler that buys equipment scrap to recover the metal and then sells the recovered metal. Once the metal comes out as bars, grain, or sponge, those sales are sales of precious metal. Businesses that straddle both sides should keep the two activities separate in their books.

Silver

Silver is on the list of precious metals in 1027.100(d). But in FinCEN Ruling 2006-1, FinCEN said it had no objection to persons who are dealers "solely by virtue of" their purchases and sales of silver not establishing AML programs until a final rule is published. The 2005 rule was issued as an interim final rule, and FinCEN had asked for comment on whether silver should stay in the definition. FinCEN's 2011 ruling (FIN-2012-R002) still described the requirement as held in abeyance for dealers in silver, and the 2006 ruling remains on FinCEN's administrative rulings page as of November 2026.

What that means in practice:

  • A business that would be a dealer only because of its silver volume is covered by the ruling.
  • A business that meets the thresholds with gold, platinum group metals, stones, or jewels is a dealer regardless of silver. The ruling does not say whether such a dealer may leave its silver trade out of its program. A dealer that excludes silver should document the basis. Covering it is the conservative choice, because the same customers and payment patterns often run through both.
  • The ruling is about the AML program only. Form 8300 for cash over $10,000 and OFAC sanctions apply to every business, silver or not.

Where this fits

  • Required of dealers by Part 1027: counting purchases and sales of covered goods under 1027.100, using metal value for finished goods, and establishing a program once both $50,000 thresholds are crossed.
  • Voluntary, above the requirement: covering a silver-only business in an AML program despite Ruling 2006-1, or covering silver within a dealer's program. A dealer that does either should say so in the program.
  • For other institutions: bank and money services business rules on precious metals transactions do not change the dealer definition.

The Dealer Guide covers what the program must contain once you are in.

Related questions

This post is general information, current as of its date. It is not legal advice.

Want this applied to your program?

We will review your current program against the rules that actually apply to you.

Talk to us